The First Door – Why people stay silent, and what an office outside the organisation changes

19. Nov 2026 | General

Armed forces, church, sport, the UN: wherever we look, a large dark field appears. Why people stay silent and what an external ombuds office changes.
Dr Andrea Hartmann-Piraudeau

Dr Andrea Hartmann-Piraudeau · November 2026

Empty meeting room with tall glass walls in calm daylight

She is sitting in her car, the engine switched off. The number is already typed in; only the call is missing. ‘What if this gets out … They’ll say I’m overreacting … He’s popular, he has influence … Maybe it really was just a remark …’ She puts the phone down on the passenger seat. Picks it up again. It is the third time this week.

Many of the conversations we have as an external ombuds office begin with exactly this moment. Even more never begin at all.

Dark field

Wherever we look, the same picture emerges

In recent years, very different institutions have looked into the dark field: the incidents that never reach any official statistic. The studies cannot be compared methodologically, as definitions, time frames and respondents differ. That makes the pattern they share all the more striking.

German armed forces. The Bundeswehr’s own research centre (ZMSBw) presented its dark-field study in November 2026: 72 per cent of female and 31 per cent of male soldiers had been verbally sexually harassed at least once during their service. Depending on the form, the unreported field is three to six times larger than what is reported.

Protestant Church in Germany. In 2024 the ForuM study counted at least 2,225 affected persons and 1,259 accused. The researchers spoke of “the tip of the tip of the iceberg”. A full review of the personnel files of a single regional church alone revealed around 60 per cent more accused and 75 per cent more affected persons.

Sport. In the SicherImSport study of more than 4,300 sports club members, 19 per cent reported sexualised violence involving physical contact, women considerably more often than men. Those affected rarely speak about it and rarely seek support from clubs or associations.

Theatre. In Thomas Schmidt’s survey of around 2,000 employees at German-speaking theatres, 55 per cent said they had experienced abuse of power at work.

The workplace. According to a study commissioned by Germany’s Federal Anti-Discrimination Agency, one in eleven employees had experienced sexual harassment at work within three years. Only a few turned to their managers or colleagues.

United Nations. In the Safe Space Survey of more than 30,000 participants, 38.7 per cent said they had experienced sexual harassment while working for the UN.

The figures differ. The picture does not. Everywhere, what is reported is only a small fraction of what people experience. Germany’s federal dark-field study LeSuBiA confirmed this for violence as a whole in February 2026: fewer than ten per cent of experiences of violence are reported.

Causes

Why people stay silent

Ask those affected why they said nothing, and the answers are remarkably similar, whether in the barracks, the parish or a UN office. In the Bundeswehr study, the most frequent reason was not wanting to cause a stir; the second was a lack of trust in reporting channels and structures. In the UN survey, 19 per cent of those who did not report cited fear for their careers. 18 per cent believed they would not be taken seriously.

Illustration: two people facing each other across a gap between two cliffs

Hierarchy adds to this. In a 2025 thematic paper on law enforcement, the Council of Europe’s Group of States against Corruption (GRECO) observes that hardly anyone reports their direct superior to someone even higher up. Anyone who reports has to turn to the very system they depend on. Cross-cultural research shows a similar pattern: high power distance inhibits official reporting above all, and unofficial reporting far less (Cheema 2022).

Conflict research tells us how little rational such weighing-up is. What will speaking cost me, and what will silence cost me? As long as a reporting channel looks like a procedure, with a file, a responsible office and foreseeable consequences, silence often weighs less.

From practice

The second layer of interest

In our work as an external ombuds office, we hear one sentence particularly often, frequently right at the start: How good that I can talk to someone who isn’t part of it. Behind it there is seldom mistrust of individuals. Behind it there is a fine sense of a second layer of interest.

Every organisation has a legitimate interest in itself: in its reputation, in its ability to function, in nothing getting out before it has been clarified. The person who comes forward usually has a different, often much simpler concern. They want to be relieved of a burden. They want something to stop.

These two interests need not conflict. But they can. People sense very precisely when an internal contact, however much personal integrity they have, is also bound to the organisation. They fear that their concern will be escalated or played down to protect the organisation. They fear being persuaded rather than heard. So they stay silent.

This has little to do with the integrity of the people who work in internal offices. It is a question of architecture.

External ombuds office

What an office outside the organisation changes

International research on ombuds offices has reached a consistent finding for years. Whether an office is used depends less on its formal design than on whether people experience it as independent.

Mary Rowe, who shaped organisational ombuds work at MIT for decades, describes the ombuds office as a “zero barrier office”: a place without a threshold, where you may ask a question before you raise a complaint (Rowe 2008). In interviews with users in Germany and the UK, Naomi Creutzfeldt has shown that people regard ombuds offices as legitimate above all when they experience them as approachable, independent and open to dialogue (Creutzfeldt 2016). Together with Ben Bradford, she demonstrates that acceptance of an outcome is closely linked to perceived procedural justice (Creutzfeldt & Bradford 2016). The OECD reaches a similar conclusion for the public sector: trust arises where independence is institutionally visible (Zuegel, Cantera & Bellantoni 2018).

Illustration: two profiles facing each other in conversation

In practice, an external ombuds office changes three things above all:

The first step triggers nothing.

A confidential conversation is not yet a procedure. Whoever calls decides what happens next: nothing, a clarifying conversation, mediation or the formal route.

The person is at the centre.

An office outside does not have to protect the organisation. It can listen without steering.

The organisation still learns.

Anonymised analyses reveal patterns that appear in no reporting statistic. Which situations and which leadership constellations repeatedly lead to incidents?

Honesty includes naming the limits clearly. An external ombuds office replaces neither disciplinary law nor criminal prosecution, neither equality officers nor works councils. Where criminal offences or acute danger are involved, the work of clarification ends. Then it is about protection, and about accompanying the person into the formal route. Its value lies in the space before and alongside, where today most cases never arrive at all.

For leaders

Questions leaders can ask themselves

How many people in your organisation know whom they can turn to without a procedure being set in motion?

Whom would you confide in yourself if it concerned a manager you respect?

What do you learn today about incidents that are never reported?

Are your reporting channels designed to process cases? Or to help people speak?

Conclusion

The door in the right place

Let us go back to the car. The woman with the number already typed in does not need a better form. She needs the certainty that her call is, for now, only a conversation. And that at the other end sits someone who has nothing to defend.

Illustration: a bridge leading out into wide, bright light

In organisations we like to read silence as a sign that all is well. In our experience it often means something else: the first door is in the wrong place. Sometimes it is enough to move it a little further outside.

References

Qualität prüfen ohne Risiko

Klären Sie in einem kurzen Vorgespräch, ob unsere Vorgehensweise zu Ihrem Fall passt. Vertraulich, strukturiert und planbar.